Comparing Organice and Orzly
I was looking for a way to connect to org mode from my phone. My main goals were to:
- Write todos when away from the computer
- Read todos when away from the computer
- Timetracking when away from the computer
In my search I came across the following possible solutions:
- org-web
- org-mode on the web, built with React, optimized for mobile, synced with Dropbox and Google Drive.
- Organice
- A community driven fork of org-web with the commitment of a Swiss company behind it.
- Orgzly
- org-mode on android, a native mobile app.
- Beorg
- org-mode on ios, a native mobile app.
- Termux
- Run emacs from termux on android. Not built with mobile in mind.
- Organic
- org-mode on android, a native mobile app; unmaintained.
For me it was easy to narrow down my choice to Organice and Orgzly (I am on Android). At that point it became difficult to decide so I gave both a try. These are my initial impressions:
Organice
Pros
- Capture templates
- Easy time tracking.
- Great user experience feel
- Agenda view
- Search functionality
- Support for checkboxes
Cons
- Offline support not as good
- No reminders
Screenshot
Orgzly
Pros
- A native android app.
- Reminders for scheduled tasks.
- Agenda view
- Offline Support
- Search functionality
Cons
- Not easy to do time tracking from mobile.
- No capture templates.
- User experience not as intuitive.
Screenshot
Conclusion
In deciding, its important to keep in mind the goals for using org mode from mobile.
- Write todos when away from the computer
- Read todos when away from the computer
- Timetracking when away from the computer
In keeping with these goals, I prefer Organice because of the capture templates and time clocking. A nicer user experience is an added bonus. Yes, Orgzly has the advantage of better offline support, but I rarely see myself without access to mobile data. Orgzly has the advantage of reminders for upcoming tasks, but I don’t rely on these types of reminders from my mobile device.
Keep in mind these are my initial impressions. My plan is to go with Organice for a few weeks and report back with anything else I notice.
Feel free to leave a comment below!